We enjoy some privileges serving on the Michigan High school Athletic Association staff.  However, one privilege we do not have is to ignore rules when we don’t enjoy their application.

One of the rules of Michigan school sports for very many years is that there is no protest of or appeal to the decisions of contest officials.  Whether it is a traveling call in basketball, a safe/out call in baseball or softball, a five-yard illegal motion call, a ten-yard holding call, or a 15-yard unsportsmanlike conduct call in football with player or coach ejection, the call is final; and if the penalty calls for next-game disqualification, that is final too.

If after a contest, an official wishes he or she could take back a call, it’s too late.  If after a contest, folks pressure an official to rescind the next-game disqualification, the outcome is unchanged: ejection from one contest for unsportsmanlike conduct requires suspension from the next day of competition.

The finality of high school officials’ calls has been challenged multiple times in courts across the country – twice in Michigan – and the nearly unanimous result nationwide has been that judges will not allow themselves to become super-referees, second guessing onsite contest officials.

On some higher levels of sports – e.g., college and professional – where there are dozens of cameras covering a handful of contests each week, league offices may review some decisions.  But our level of sports lacks sophisticated cameras positioned at all angles, and it involves many hundreds of contests in several different sports every week.  We have neither the time nor the technology at every venue to be involved in reviewing the calls of contest officials.

Last school year, there were nearly 1,000 player ejections and more than 200 coach ejections. School sports is not equipped to review 30 to 40 of these situations that arise each week; nor should we do so.

Officials see a play and make an instantaneous decision.  Their calls are final; and living with the outcome is one of the valuable lessons we try to teach and learn in school-based sports.


Wednesday, August 23, 2017 10:09 PM
It is an excellent decision to not allow protest or appeals. This is the extension of the classroom and all involved must understand that this is another side of academia. Young people need to understand the social psychology of being competitive, having fun, and interaction with people. It is not just about wins and loses. At this level it is truly about how you play the game!

Post Comment

Only registered users may post comments.

From the Director

From the Director is the official MHSAA Blog which will touch on pertinent school sports topics periodically throughout the school year from various MHSAA Staff.